In Ghosts and Empties, I noticed how “yell” was used to signify more
than just yelling, but the effects of her temper on her family, “…whose little
children walk around with frozen, watchful faces…” (Groff, 1). I felt that told the reader a lot without going
into detail about what the narrator has done.
I
felt the narrator’s disdain for her neighborhood by how they describe the
Spanish moss as, “…dangling like armpit hair…” (Groff 3). Later another character describes the Spanish
moss as more sinister, “…Spanish moss and vines that looked from the corners of
her eyes like snake.” (Groff 276). This
shows how different the moss can look to different characters, depending on who
they are and what their situation is.
As
the narrator moves around her neighborhood she slips into imagination about the
real people who live around her, “…the nuns in full regalia in their
shelter…while, aboveground, all has been blasted black…” (Groff 6). She also imagines the woman with the Great Dane
needing medical attention and the dog acting as a stretcher. The narrator observes and rounds out her
neighborhood with imagined stories and interactions with people she will
probably never talk to.
At
the end of the story, the narrator imagines her house, absent herself, much
like she imagines the lives of her neighbors that she doesn’t get to witness. Here, her body far away from them, she feels
that she can love them without the other complicated emotions that get in the
way.
I
got the sense that the older sister, in Dogs
Go Wolf, is used to caring for her younger sister. She is used to telling her bedtimes stories,
and on page 68 she dresses her sister’s wound without thinking about asking the
adults for help. The adults, and the
dog, both abandon the girls.
On
page 91 there is a flash-forward that lets us know they survive. Just when the reader is the most doubtful of
the sisters’ fate, the author introduces their future. Instead of being wholly comforting, we learn
about the younger sister’s doomed marriage.
This seems to be an important time that the older sister thinks back to
the island. The end of the story is
focused on their rescue, we have already had a glimpse into what lies ahead for
them.
In
the beginning of Above and Below, the
main character kicks her cat out and is scratched. It reminded me of Dogs Go Wolf, animals turning on humans in a way, but here the cat
has more reason to be angry. The
scratches she receives become scars, and seem to remind her of the life she
lost.
At
the start of the story I found her memories of her life before sad, but they
become more and more painful to read later on, after she’s gone through more
difficulties, I found my sympathy for her had grown.
I
thought it was interesting how, when she surrenders Jane’s children, she is
still waiting for her mother to help her.
She isn’t the children’s mother, but I thought it was interesting how
she still believes in mothers even after Jane has difficulty providing, her
mother hasn’t helped her, and she herself isn’t willing or able to help the
children temporarily in her care.
This
story ends with a birth, it’s clear time has passed, but I’m not sure how much,
and it’s unclear what her life is like at the time of the birth. I felt the ending was more ambiguous, the
mysteries of death and birth feel connected here. The darkness of when she is lost and the fear
of birth are connected, which made me think the “glow” in the dark that was her
survival that night, is the same as her chance of survival while giving birth.
-Iris
I think the moment with the "flash forward" in 'Dogs go Wolf' is really interesting, because in reading it I also thought it was a true flash to the girls futures at first, but then as I was reading it, I wondered if it really was. The way the line "she'd become a lawyer" is phrased, to me, sounds more like the way a preteen or young adolescent might talk about an imagined future. "I'd become a___," "she'd become a ___." Then moving on to where she keeps starting the line, "once upon a time," and the use of "floating" in the next section, all make me wonder if this "flash forward" is really just the older sister imagining a future once they get off the island. Imagining how she would get back at the men she felt wronged them, by "using [their language] against them", remaining in the powerful position between the sisters, and imagining her sister essentially staying infantilized by men as she seeks comfort from any source no matter how unhealthy (like the bananas), like the mother and Melanie. As there is no confirmation in the ending that the girls are taken from the island, I have to wonder if they ever did. After all, the ending only says that they took the woman's cries as welcome, and ran, but not that they were welcomed, or rescued.
ReplyDeleteI appreciate hearing yours and Iris's perspectives about the effect of the flashforward (in my copy it's on page 63). My perspective is that it feels written truly from the future. To me, the tone departs from that of a child's; it becomes lyrical and descriptive beyond a child's capability: "She'd learn the language of men and use it against them." The narrative of the future also becomes too specific to feel imagined, to me: "He made her give up her last name, which the older sister had fought their whole childhood to keep, though their third foster parents had wanted to adopt them..."
DeleteI definitely agree that the ending left things ambiguous-feeling. The reader never gets complete satisfaction that they leave the island, like they have to be caught in this limbo forever.
We never get a rescue or a sequence that leads up to a future, referred to in Dogs Go Wolf or Above..but those delicately placed flash forwards that what? give us hope or allow us to imagine the intervening years? Interesting strategy.
ReplyDelete